The right to act, to think, to speak, to print, is the surest
way to protect the liberties, and continue the full measure of
independence which America so richly possesses. In these rights
lies the means of creating a public opinion representative of
the entire Nation. This liberty is indispensable to further social,
economic, and political development. Clash of opinions creates
interest and thought on all public questions. A realization of
the force of public opinion expressed by the ballot, awakens
a sense of responsibility that compels the best minds to give
careful study to any subject that vitally concerns our Nation.
Through the present means of communication, the people are daily
informed in every matter of national or international import.
Abuses. - This privilege does not permit the publication
of libels or other matter injurious to public morals or private
reputation. Like all liberties granted under the broad principles
of the Constitution, these rights are abused to the detriment
of the best interests of the people.
Propaganda. - Propaganda floods our country from every
conceivable source. Active and vociferous agencies have been
organized for the express purpose of advancing doctrines absolutely
not in accord with the fixed principles of our Nation. In the
most persistent manner they seek to tear down rather than build,
to destroy rather than improve. One of their most subtly dangerous
features is that it is so camouflaged as to make it appear to
have an innocent purpose.
To prevent such activities during the World War, Congress found
it necessary to pass the espionage act of 1917 for the safety
of the State and the successful outcome of the struggle.
We carefully supervise every agency whose business may in any
degree affect the physical health of our people. Equal care should
be exercised over all agencies which in any manner may affect
our social, economic, or political life.
Restriction of abuses. - There is no law in any state
or nation that prohibits freedom of speech or press, but there
are laws against the abuse of this right. Restrictions may be
necessary for the preservation of public order and the protection
of the State. While Congress is forbidden by the Constitution
to abridge the freedom of speech or the press, the punishment
of those who violate every principle of loyalty and patriotism
modifies in no manner the constitutional provision. The law punishes
because of the crime against the country and its citizens.
The first amendment "can not have been, and obviously was
not, intended to give immunity for every possible use of language."
- Justice Holmes.
Blackstone's maxims, which help to interpret the present limitation
on speech and press:
(1) Between public and private rights the public rights must
prevail.
(2) Liberty to all, but preference to none.
(3) Those offenses should be most severely punished which are
most difficult to guard against. |